Harambee Stars coach Benni McCarthy has explained why only defenders stepped up to take penalties during Kenya’s painful shootout defeat to Madagascar in the CHAN 2024 quarter-final.
Kenya were eliminated 4-3 on penalties after a tense 1-1 draw in regulation and extra time. Alphonce Omija had given the Stars the lead with a towering header early in the second half, but Madagascar responded through Fenohasina Razafimaro’s spot-kick, forcing the game into extra time and eventually penalties.
What caught the attention of many supporters was that all of Kenya’s five penalty takers were defenders. Siraj Mohammed, Daniel Sakari, and Sylvester Owino confidently converted their efforts, but Michael Kibwage and Omija missed, allowing Madagascar to advance to the semi-finals despite goalkeeper Byrne Omondi pulling off a crucial save earlier in the shootout.
Speaking after the game, McCarthy revealed that he does not compel players to take penalties, instead leaving it to those who feel confident enough to handle the pressure.
“I don’t force people to take penalties. We had practiced spot-kicks in training, but the atmosphere inside the stadium, with over 40,000 fans watching, creates a completely different kind of pressure,” said McCarthy. “Some players develop fear, and I respect that. I would rather go with those who are brave enough to step forward.”
The coach, himself a former striker renowned for his composure from the spot during his playing days, explained that he fully shoulders the responsibility when a player misses. According to him, what matters most is confidence in the moment rather than position or reputation.
“I prefer players who feel strong enough to handle the occasion. If they miss, that is on me because I gave them the freedom to decide. It is not easy for every player, no matter how talented, to stand up in such a moment. Penalties are a high-pressure test that requires mental toughness, not just technical ability,” McCarthy added.
While attacking players are traditionally expected to lead in shootouts, defenders often prove just as reliable. In Kenya’s case, their first three spot-kicks were converted flawlessly before nerves crept in. The coach’s philosophy highlights the unpredictable nature of penalty shootouts and the immense mental strength required to succeed.
