A Los Angeles judge has resentenced Erik and Lyle Menendez convicted of murdering their parents in 1989 to 50 years to life, making them eligible for parole after more than three decades behind bars.
Judge Michael Jesic delivered the new sentence on Tuesday, citing recent legal guidelines that allow for reconsideration of life without parole sentences in certain cases. While acknowledging the severity of the murders, he praised the brothers’ “remarkable” rehabilitation efforts during their incarceration.
The Menendez brothers, who were 18 and 21 at the time of the killings, claimed they acted in self-defence after enduring years of sexual abuse from their father, Jose Menendez. Their brutal crime committed in their Beverly Hills mansion captivated national attention, inspiring books, documentaries, and a recent Netflix drama.
In emotional courtroom statements, Erik and Lyle expressed remorse and described the terror they now believe their parents must have felt in their final moments. Both spoke of their desire to help other inmates and sex abuse survivors if given the opportunity for release.
The decision was met with mixed reactions. Family members and supporters welcomed the ruling, with cousin Anamaria Baralt declaring it “a great day” and advocating for the brothers’ release. Defence attorney Mark Geragos called the resentencing “one huge step closer to bringing the boys home.”
However, the Los Angeles District Attorney’s office strongly opposed the reduced sentence, arguing that the brothers have not fully taken responsibility and continue to deflect blame. Prosecutors pointed to decades of alleged dishonesty, including false testimony and deception following the murders.
A critical next step lies ahead: the California parole board will hold a hearing on June 13 to determine if the Menendez brothers can be released. Governor Gavin Newsom is also reviewing a clemency request, with a risk assessment already completed—reportedly identifying the brothers as a “moderate risk of violence.”
As the June hearing approaches, the nation remains divided over whether the Menendez brothers, now aged 54 and 57, deserve a second chance at life outside prison.
