Kileleshwa MCA Robert Alai has denied owning a Facebook account that allegedly published defamatory statements about media personality Fred Machoka. The case, filed by Machoka, accuses Alai of writing harmful comments on his Facebook account. However, Alai, through his legal representatives, asserted that he does not have a Facebook account, nor does he operate any social media platforms under his name or any alias.
In his defense, Alai emphasized that he has never met, heard of, or interacted with Fred Machoka. He further stated that he had no knowledge of Machoka’s public standing or reputation, and thus could not have made defamatory statements about him. Alai also clarified that his full name is Robert Alai Onyango, and he is not the individual being referred to in the defamation suit, which only names “Robert Alai.”
The controversial MCA rejected the claims made by Machoka’s lawyer, Danstan Omari, who argued that Alai’s disavowal of the social media account seemed like a case of mistaken identity. Omari pointed out that while Machoka is still open to an out-of-court settlement, it remains difficult to proceed with such negotiations when the defendant denies any involvement.
Alai’s defense also extended to a request for the court to dismiss the case entirely, urging that there is no valid reason for him to be involved in the matter. He further argued that the case lacks merit and that he should not bear any costs related to the lawsuit.
This legal battle highlights the growing issues surrounding online identity and defamation, with individuals increasingly using social media to make allegations and seek legal redress for perceived wrongdoings. The case continues to unfold, and it remains to be seen whether the matter will be resolved in court or through an out-of-court settlement.
