For decades, the Soweto Derby between Kaizer Chiefs and Orlando Pirates has been South Africa’s most iconic football fixture, known for its electrifying atmosphere, passionate fans, and deep-rooted rivalry. However, recent seasons have seen a dramatic shift in the balance of power within South African football, with many now questioning whether the derby still holds the same weight it once did.
Former Bafana Bafana star Teko Modise believes that the modern rivalry between Mamelodi Sundowns and Orlando Pirates has overtaken the Soweto Derby in terms of football quality and competitiveness. Modise, who played for both Pirates and Sundowns, argues that while the Soweto Derby remains significant historically, it no longer represents the best football spectacle in the country.
Traditionally, Chiefs and Pirates were the dominant forces in the Premier Soccer League (PSL), attracting huge fan bases across the nation and even beyond Africa. Their clashes would bring the country to a standstill, symbolizing the essence of South African football culture. Yet, their recent struggles have dulled that magic.
Kaizer Chiefs have endured a particularly difficult period, failing to win the league title since 2015 and finishing outside the top eight in the past two seasons. Their rivals, Orlando Pirates, have shown some resurgence in recent years but have not lifted the PSL trophy since 2012. In contrast, Mamelodi Sundowns have completely dominated the domestic scene, winning eight consecutive league titles and ten of the last twelve overall.
Sundowns’ consistent success both locally and on the continental stage has redefined excellence in South African football. They have reached the CAF Champions League quarter-finals or beyond in nearly every campaign over the past decade. Moreover, they contribute the majority of players to the national team, a testament to their superior quality and structure.
Modise’s remarks have sparked heated reactions among Chiefs supporters, many of whom see the Soweto Derby as a cultural institution rather than just a football match. Yet, the statistics and performances suggest a changing reality. While the Soweto Derby still commands emotional loyalty, the clash between Sundowns and Pirates now represents the pinnacle of South African football in terms of skill, form, and competition.
The debate highlights a new era in South African football—one where tradition and modern dominance collide, forcing fans to reconsider what truly defines the “biggest game” in the nation.
